Yesterday, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”) announced that it fined Deutsche Bank Securities $7.5 million for negligently misrepresenting delinquency data in connection with the issuance of subprime securities. In settling the matter, Deutsche Bank Securities neither admitted nor denied the charges, but consented to the entry of FINRA’s findings.
FINRA determined that Deutsche Bank Securities negligently misrepresented and underreported the percentages of mortgages that were delinquent in the prospectus supplements of six subprime residential mortgage backed securities (MBS) that were issued in 2006. FINRA added that Deutsche Bank Securities failed to correct errors by a third party vendor and servicers, which underreported the historical delinquency rates of the mortgages in connection with its offer and sale of 16 additional subprime MBS issued in 2007. Further, FINRA said, Deutsche Bank Securities failed to establish a system to supervise its reporting of required historical delinquency information.
“It is critically important that firms provide accurate information for their customers to use in evaluating investments,” said James S. Shorris, FINRA Executive Vice President and Acting Chief of Enforcement. “Future returns on subprime securitizations are affected by mortgage holders who fail to make loan payments. Delinquency rates constitute material information for investors. Deutsche Bank Securities’ failure to ensure that the delinquency information was accurate is an unacceptable failure to meet this important obligation.”
Delinquency rates constitute material information for MBS investments because that data affects the investor’s ability to evaluate the fair market value, the yields on the certificates and the anticipated holding periods of each of these securitizations. Investors may consider this information in assessing the profitability of these securitizations and in determining whether future returns would be disrupted by mortgage holders who fail to make loan payments.
During 2006 and 2007, Deutsche Bank Securities underwrote subprime MBS and sold them to institutional investors. FINRA determined that in the prospectus supplements of six subprime securitizations worth approximately $2.2 billion offered in March 2006, the firm described a method of calculating delinquencies that was in fact different from the method it actually used. As a result, delinquencies were underreported. For example, in one MBS deal, Deutsche Bank Securities reported that under its described method of calculation, 8.75 percent of the loans were between 30 – 59 days delinquent, corresponding to $14 million in delinquent loans. But the actual delinquency numbers computed under the method Deutsche Bank Securities disclosed were significantly higher, with 24.02 percent of the loans between 30 – 59 days delinquent, corresponding to $38.5 million in delinquent loans.
FINRA also found that Deutsche Bank Securities negligently underreported historical delinquency rates on a website the firm maintained that was referenced in prospectus materials in connection with the sale of 16 MBS.
Issuers of subprime MBS are required to disclose historical performance information for prior securitizations that contain similar mortgage loans as collateral. That information, which includes historical delinquency rates, is called “static pool” information – and it is one of the disclosure requirements for asset-backed securities under Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Regulation AB. After Regulation AB became effective in December 2005, Deutsche Bank Securities prospectus supplements for new subprime MBS offerings informed investors they could view static pool information on the firm’s Regulation AB website.
According to FINRA, in January 2007, Deutsche Bank Securities learned that the outside vendor it retained to populate its Regulation AB website was underreporting delinquencies as a result of errors made by the servicers responsible for tracking delinquencies. Deutsche Bank Securities was able to determine that these errors affected 16 securitizations and was able to provide corrected delinquency data for 13 of them to the vendor to use going forward. But the vendor failed to use the corrected data. The firm never ensured that the vendor posted the corrected static pool information and continued to refer investors to the inaccurate information about these 13 securitizations on the Regulation AB website. While Deutsche Bank Securities was not able to determine the extent to which delinquency rates were underreported in the remaining three affected securitizations, the firm continued to use this data without indicating on its Regulation AB website that the information was inaccurate.
Presently, KlaymanToskes is prosecuting numerous arbitration claims on behalf of aggrieved investors to recover losses sustained in mortgage-backed securities and structured asset-backed securities. These claims have been filed with FINRA Dispute Resolution. The attorneys at KlaymanToskes are dedicated to pursuing claims on behalf of investors who have suffered investment losses. It continues its representation of investors throughout the world in securities arbitration and litigation matters against major Wall Street brokerage firms.